Carrier Name Phone Fax  Email
A. Central 866-222-2242 607-965-2250  claim_user@nycm.com
AIG (commercial only) 877-399-6442 N/A
Allegheny Coop 800-887-9474 585-968-6016
Andover 800-225-0770 800-323-5112
Atlantic Mutual 800-945-7461 800-678-9847
Central Insurance 877-346-0300 N/A
One Beacon Insurance Group 877-248-3455 N/A
CNA Insurance 877-262-2727 N/A
Crum and Forster 800-690-5520
Chubb Insurance 800-252-4670 800-300-2538  cscfnol@chubb.com
Dryden Mutual 800-556-5802 607-844-3526
Erie and Niagara 716-632-5433 716-632-0410
Fireman’s Fund (Commercial) 888-347-3428 800-511-3720
Fireman’s Fund (Personal) 888-347-3428 800-448-9733
Foremost 800-527-3907 877-452-3957  claims.mail@foremost.com
GMAC 800-325-1088 336-726-2300
Hanover 800-628-0250 800-399-4734
Harleysville 800-892-8877 800-441-4118
Hartford Commercial 800-327-3636 800-347-8197
Hartford Personal 800-243-5860 877-536-4765
Kemper 888–252–2799 315-449-8939
LoVullo 800-876-3065 716-856-8057
Merchants 888-644-6680 800-235-6304  centralclaims@merchantsgroup.com
MetLife (Personal only) 800-854-6011 866-743-1546
MiddleOak 800-225-2533 978-744-5677
National Grange (Main Street America) 877-425-2467 877-282-3844  fnol@msagroup.com
New York Central 888-234-6926 607-965-2136  claim_user@nycm.com
Peerless 800-522-7152 877-321-9885 peerlessnewloss@peerless-ins.com
claimsmailpic@peerless-ins.com
Philadelphia 800-765-9749 800-685-9238
Preferred Mutual 800-333-7642 607-847-6616  claims@preferredmutual.com
Progressive 800-274-4499 N/A
Safeco 800-332-3226 678-417-3333
Selective 866-455-9969 804-422-6135
Sterling 800-462-4661 518-234-8570
Tower Group 888-856-5522 888-291-6262
Travlers (Commercial) 800-238-6225 N/A
Travelers (Personal) 800-252-4633 N/A
Trident 877-474-8808 877-312-8842
Utica National 800-274-1914 315-235-6767
Zurich/Maryland Claim Center (New York Commercial Lines) 800-987-3373 800-887-1335
Zurich/Maryland Claim Center (New York Personal Lines) 888-243-8789 888-503-2236
 Vermont Mutual Ins. Co 800-451-5000 claimsecomm@vermontmutual.com